A Case Of Too Many ‘Experts’ In The CIA?

By: - January 17, 2018

Mohr argues that the integrity of the product suffers due to a lack of “true experts” combined with the collective pressure to “be” a “Subject Matter Expert,” or SME.

Two weeks ago, Lee Ferran, an Emmy Award-winning investigative journalist (and founder of Code and Dagger), put forth an article entitled, “In Intelligence Analysis, Too Many Experts Without Real Expertise.” Thus is the assertion of Defense Intelligence Agency analyst John Mohr, who authored “A Call for More Humility in Intelligence Analysis,” as published in the CIA’S unclassified Studies in Intelligence Journal. In it, Mohr argues that the integrity of the product suffers due to a lack of “true experts” combined with the collective pressure to “be” a “Subject Matter Expert,” or SME.

Mohr writes:

[I]ntelligence analysts [are] staking their reputations on their specialized knowledge, in addition to solid tradecraft and polished communication skills. No analyst would want to be introduced [in a meeting] as a novice on North Korea, and no manager would want to turn away a tasking because the office lacks expertise, but the IC needs to guard against applying the SME title too broadly and consider what really constitutes an expert.

Based on my experience, my perspective on the issue is consistent with that of longtime former CIA analyst Nada Bakos as presented in Ferran’s report—Mohr was erroneously conflating humility and analytic tradecraft.

In presentation, an analyst is not representing themselves or their own independent analysis, but is speaking on behalf of CIA. Furthermore, the analysis of any one issue is developed through an editing and coordination process involving many individuals with many levels of “expertise” (from novice to journeyman to experienced expert) on the task or issue at hand. Also, in this process is embedded lessons learned such as analytic failings of the past as well as dissenting opinions, which are hashed out and annotated accordingly.

Reading this left me uncertain as to Mohr’s motivation, or exactly what issue the author was seeking to address beyond perceived pomposity in the Intelligence Community, specifically at the CIA. I took from it, maybe mistakenly, that the author was responding to experiences in the inter-agency coordination process and the friction between and among analysts defending ‘their’ analysis. There are serious issues with intelligence analysis, exacerbated by politicization and personalities.

Mohr’s assertion also underscores the merits of all-source analysis regardless of the “expert” egos involved, or lack thereof. Collaboration between analyst and collector may skew the objectivity of the analysis more by relying too heavily on that which is local or corporate whether HUMINT, SIGINT, military or civilian, etc. Critically, this over-reliance may get passed on in the process and lost in the analytic dialogue of “experts,” real or imagined.

It is my opinion that analysis should be conducted under the authority of the Director of National Intelligence (DNI), vice the separate agencies comprising the Intelligence Community. This would provide an all-source perspective and limit the potential for institutional bias. The respective agencies would produce estimates or assessments, and provide direct analytic support to their collectors, but not analysis.

  • RSS WND

    • Alejandro Mayorkas: The worst traitor in American history
      I swear we are living in some kind of bizarro "Twilight Zone" episode, or a zombie apocalypse nightmare. Things are that bizarre in America nowadays. Forty-eight hours ago, I was watching a TV show on CBS when a promotion came on my TV screen for the CBS morning show. Host Gayle King (Oprah Winfrey's BFF)… […]
    • The hypocrisy of Earth Day
      We are approaching Earth Day, the international celebration in which progressive politicians and celebrities exempt themselves from the green legislation they helped create, a celebration of the astounding ability of people to ignore laws of economics, physics and common sense in an effort to pretend their carbon footprint is impossibly dainty. Many participants are invited… […]
    • Israel's 'Iran-Lite' strike: Was it just Act 1?
      As a young boy occasionally able to attend the Washington, D.C., July 4 fireworks, I always excitedly awaited the big bang illuminating the nighttime sky with an impressive array of "bombs bursting in air" signaling the end of the show. For those who expected a similar show in Israel's retaliatory attack against Iran on April… […]
    • Justice for outies NOW!
      Things seem to be progressing quite well at Harvard University with regards to diversity. If things keep on pace, soon everybody who graduates will be singled out as diversely unique and have his/her/zhr own ceremony. Each graduate will have their sufferings, aggressions, and moments of glory recognized in the wake of a multitude of lifetime… […]
    • Dumb is the new smart: The rise of the Idiocracy
      By Ed Thompson Smartism is the absurd idea that smart is bad. The bias against intelligence is exemplified by vacuous celebrities spouting on serious subjects and social media influencers on Instagram and YouTube who get rich by vomiting out useless drivel. One would think that dumb as the new smart reached rock bottom with TikTok.… […]
    • From Pence to Johnson, evangelicals are failing their political mandate
      (THE BLAZE) -- es, Donald Trump is a mess at times. And, from the church’s perspective, there is an undeniable element of Barabbas about him for too many people who are not content with “he’d clearly be a better president than the current dementia patient” and who must instead must elevate him as a 21st-century… […]
    • Israel sends a message – but we're not near 'the end'
      Is the conflict between Israel and Iran about to explode? Are we on the edge of World War III, if not Armageddon? The answer to all these questions is the same: not likely. But in saying this I do not claim supernatural, prophetic insight. Rather, my remarks are based on a general understanding of Scripture,… […]
    • A message of life & death
      Editor's note: The following video is presented by Pastor Daniel Joseph, president and founder of Corner Fringe Ministries. Subscribe to the Corner Fringe YouTube channel here. The post A message of life & death appeared first on WND.
    • Iran's attack on Israel: A sign of the times
      Iran's attack on Israel on April 13, 2024, was without precedent. And it has prophetic significance, because the increasing isolation of Israel is one of the signs of the times that Jesus told us to be looking for. In the 21st chapter of Luke's gospel, Jesus gave the disciples a bird's-eye view of end-times events.… […]
    • Supreme Court to put politician on trial for Christianity a THIRD time
      Twice already, courts in Finland have cleared politician Paivi Rasanen of hate speech charges for simply posting a Bible verse. That's not good enough for the prosecutor, who insisted he would take his efforts to punish her for her biblical views to the nation's Supreme Court. And now that body has agreed to review the… […]
  • Enter My WorldView