What the Alabama IVF Ruling Says About the Right to Life

By: - February 29, 2024

Source link

A ruling by the Alabama Supreme Court last week has been the cause of immense hyperventilating in the mainstream press—and the predictable invocation of scare terms like “theocracy” and “Christian nationalism.”

In LePage v. Center for Reproductive Medicine, P.C., a fertility clinic that neglected to properly secure its frozen embryo nursery from a prying patient was found in breach of Alabama’s Wrongful Death of a Minor Act, after several embryos were killed.

The parents of the dead embryos were within their rights to sue the clinic, the court found.

In penning the majority opinion, Justice Jay Mitchell explained that the state’s highest court had consistently viewed an unborn child as a “minor” under the statute, regardless of his or her stage of development.

As lawyer and commentator Josh Hammer has pointed out, “Crucially, neither the plaintiffs nor defendants contested this understanding, and the question was not before the court.”

So, why does this case matter? What does it have to do with one of the most fundamental rights—the right to life?

At issue, writes Hammer, was “whether the court should legislate from the bench and decree that which the Alabama legislature had opted not to do itself”—namely, to remove longstanding legal protections from certain unborn lives simply because they happen to be located outside of a womb.

“The court, appropriately, declined to do so,” Hammer summarizes. “That’s it. That’s the whole case.”

What really drew the ire of America’s media overlords, however, was the concurring opinion of Chief Justice Tom Parker, who appealed to Christian teachings to buttress Alabama’s commitment to the sanctity of life. He argued that the word “sanctity” has little meaning outside of a Judeo-Christian context:

In summary, the theologically based view of the sanctity of life adopted by the People of Alabama encompasses the following: (1) God made every person in His image; (2) each person therefore has a value that far exceeds the ability of human beings to calculate; and (3) human life cannot be wrongfully destroyed without incurring the wrath of a holy God, who views the destruction of His image as an affront to Himself.

Beyond the book of Genesis, Chief Justice Parker quoted several other verses, including Jeremiah 1:5—“When I had not yet formed you in the womb, I knew you”—along with theologians Thomas Aquinas and John Calvin.

Typical of the pressroom reactions against the ruling was a USA Today column that set aside all historical context in Alabama to scoff that “abortion opponents say life begins at conception, and even a handful of cells deserves the same legal protections as a person.”

The authors lined up abortion activists and other secularists to frame the court’s references to God variously as “out of bounds,” “extreme,” “problematic,” “a path to theocracy,” and a “middle finger” to America.

One of their favored experts was Rachel Laser, president and CEO of Americans United for Separation of Church and State, a non-profit based in  Washington, D.C.

“She saw the verdict in Alabama as part of a larger Christian nationalist movement—the idea that America was created by and for Christians and its laws should reflect that,” they wrote.

The authors then quoted a warning from Laser: “The agenda doesn’t stop with reproductive rights. It’s much, much bigger. And that should concern every American, because America wouldn’t be America without the separation of church and state.”

In the days since, MSNBC has leaned into  the “Christian nationalism” scare campaign in discussing the broader context of a looming Trump re-election. In a video that quickly went viral, a guest appearing on ‘All In With Chris Hayes’ gave the game away when she asserted:

The thing that unites them as Christian nationalists … is that they believe that our rights as Americans, as all human beings, don’t come from any earthly authority—they don’t come from Congress, they don’t come from the Supreme Court—they come from God.

Never mind the U.S. Declaration of Independence, drafted by Thomas Jefferson and signed by 55 other American Founding Fathers, which states, “We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness.”

In case you missed it, according to left-wing talking points, the Founding Fathers of the United States were Christian nationalists.

Notice that Christians who invoke the Bible and theology to advocate for progressive politics are conveniently exempted from this self-serving standard.

The playbook is simple: label any Christian impulse for conservative policy as “Christian nationalism” and it goes away.

Again, Josh Hammer cuts through the fog:

America was quite literally founded on the notion that ‘all men are created equal’ and that ‘they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights.’ Thomas Jefferson, the man who penned those words but redacted his Bible to remove those parts he did not himself believe, was about the furthest thing imaginable from an Orthodox [sic] Christian. Yet even Jefferson held that our rights flow from our Creator—the very God, we know from Genesis, who made man in His image. The political theory of the American founding is that man is made in God’s image and that we accordingly possess certain rights that no other man or ruler can deny.

“This is not ‘theocracy,’ he concludes. “It is basic American history.”

The good news? Christians need not be ashamed of America’s cross-pollinating religious and political heritage.

After all, that’s what preserved for us the right to life in the first place.

Image credit: Pexels


    • 'Shut Up and Sing' still applies to emotional celebs
      When Laura Ingraham wrote her book "Shut Up and Sing" in 2003, the Left didn't read the book as much as overreact to the title. The title implied something important. While celebrities gain a "platform" they feel compelled to use, do their opinions reflect any expertise? Or is fame more important than logic? Celebrities often… […]
    • Iran says it could pursue nuclear weapons if Israel threatens atomic sites
      (ZEROHEDGE) – Iran's leadership has always strongly asserted that it is not pursuing the development of nuclear weapons, but instead has long sought a peaceful nuclear energy program. Various Ayatollahs over the decades have even declared the atomic bomb to be 'unIslamic' and against the teachings of the Koran. But that could change, Iran's military… […]
    • Ask not for whom the bell tolls, it tolls for EVs
      By H. Sterling Burnett Electric vehicles (EVs) have been all the rage among politicians since at least President Obama's first term in office, but they've never really caught on among the unwashed masses. Average folks with jobs, shopping to do, errands to run and kids to transport actually want their cars to deliver them to… […]
    • Google fires 28 employees involved in sit-in protest over $1.2 billion Israel contract
      (NEW YORK POST) – Google has fired 28 employees over their participation in a 10-hour sit-in at the search giant’s offices in New York and Sunnyvale, California, to protest the company’s business ties with the Israel government, The Post has learned. The pro-Palestinian staffers — who wore traditional Arab headscarves as they stormed and occupied… […]
    • Growing Latino support for border wall … and for Trump
      A new poll by Axios and Noticias Telemundo finds that 42% of Latino Americans support building a wall or fence along the entire U.S.-Mexico border. When pollsters asked the same question in December 2021, the number was 30%. That's a significant increase as the border crisis created by President Joe Biden's policies worsens. It's also… […]
    • College suspends professor 'energized' by Hamas attack on Israel
      (THE COLLEGE FIX) – A tenured professor is suspended throughout the rest of the semester after writing an essay celebrating Hamas’ attack on Israel. “McCarthyism is real. I’ve been relieved of teaching responsibilities,” Hobart and William Smith Colleges Professor Jodi Dean wrote Saturday on X. “Don’t stop talking about Palestine.” Get the hottest, most important… […]
    • O.J. Simpson is dead – Ron & Nicole are unavailable for comment
      As to the double murder case against O.J. Simpson, there was so much evidence that his guilt was obvious. This evidence included, but was not limited to, blood at the crime scene and on and in Simpson's white Bronco; a bloody glove found at the crime scene and a matching glove found at Simpson's home;… […]
    • How Greg Norman saved the Clinton presidency and other golf stories
      In their weekly podcast, Hollywood veteran Loy Edge and longtime WND columnist Jack Cashill skirt the everyday politics downstream and travel merrily upstream to the source of our extraordinary culture. The post How Greg Norman saved the Clinton presidency and other golf stories appeared first on WND.
    • The deadly price for Obama's ongoing foreign-policy legacy
      If a belligerent state launched 185 explosive drones, 36 cruise missiles and 110 surface-to-surface missiles from three fronts against civilian targets within the United States, would President Joe Biden call it a "win"? Would the president tell us that the best thing we can do now is show "restraint"? What if that same terror state's… […]
    • Growing movement hopes to disenfranchise small-state voters
      The structure of the American government was designed by the founders to prevent raw majoritarianism: the three branches of government and their checks and balances, the allocation of power between the state and federal governments, constitutional limits on the federal government's power, the differing composition of the U.S. House of Representatives and the U.S. Senate,… […]
  • Enter My WorldView