The 9th Circuit’s Dangerous and Unprecedented Use of Campaign Statements to Block Presidential Policy

Tags: , ,

By Eugene Kontorovich, The Washington Post:

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the 9th Circuit has just upheld a nationwide temporary injunction on President Trump’s executive order relating to refugees and visas from certain countries. I think the court’s opinion is weak in most respects, but I will address one of the most interesting and potentially far-reaching aspects.

Generally, the president has vast discretion in issuing visas. One of the major arguments against the executive order is that while in principle a president can limit immigration from the seven affected countries, it would be unconstitutional for President Trump in particular to do so, because in his case the action is motivated by impermissible religious bias. The central exhibit for this argument is his campaign statements about a “Muslim ban.”

While the 9th Circuit did not address this at great length, focusing instead on due-process arguments, it did accept the basic validity of the form of the states’ argument. “The States’ claims raise serious allegations and present significant constitutional questions,” wrote the court.

There is absolutely no precedent for courts looking to a politician’s statements from before he or she took office, let alone campaign promises, to establish any kind of impermissible motive. The 9th Circuit fairly disingenuously cites several Supreme Court cases that show “that evidence of purpose beyond the face of the challenged law may be considered in evaluating Establishment and Equal Protection Clause claims.” But the cases it mentions do nothing more than look at legislative history — the formal process of adopting the relevant measure. That itself goes too far for textualists, but it provides absolutely no support for looking before the start of the formal deliberations on the measure to the political process of electing its proponents.

To read rest of article visit The Washington Post.

  • RSS WND

    • Turley rips Hillary for attacking Trump over payments despite her campaign being fined for Steele dossier
      By Harold Hutchison Daily Caller News Foundation George Washington University law professor Jonathan Turley skewered former First Lady Hillary Clinton Thursday for attacking former President Donald Trump over the alleged payout to porn star Stormy Daniels. Clinton appeared on Morning Joe, where she alleged that the $130,000 payout to Daniels in 2016 was a form… […]
    • Changing tune: Vulnerable senator co-sponsors Laken Riley Act weeks after opposing
      By Mary Lou Masters Daily Caller News Foundation Democratic Montana Sen. Jon Tester appears to be changing his tune on supporting the Republican-led Laken Riley Act, named after the 22-year-old nursing student who was allegedly murdered by an illegal alien in  February on the University of Georgia’s campus. Tester voted with Democrats on March 23… […]
    • State slapped with suit over law allowing illegals to be arrested, deported
      By Jake Smith Daily Caller News Foundation A number of civil rights groups filed a lawsuit against the state of Iowa on Thursday for passing a law allowing authorities to arrest and detain some illegal immigrants. SF 2340, signed by Republican Gov. Kim Reynolds, grants local and state law enforcement the ability to arrest and… […]
    • BLM sues massive liberal foundation: 'Egregious mismanagement' of $33 million
      By Robert Schmad Daily Caller News Foundation A liberal foundation controlling roughly $1 billion in assets faces accusations of “egregious mismanagement” of funds from the largest Black Lives Matter group in the country. Black Lives Matter Global Network Foundation (BLM GNF) filed a lawsuit on Monday accusing the Tides Foundation of mishandling funds donated to… […]
    • Just plane nuts! Woman naps inside aircraft's overhead luggage bin
      (NEW YORK POST) -- This sleepy traveler has bin places. A Southwest Airlines passenger flummoxed fellow flyers after she was filmed napping in the plane’s overhead bin, as seen in a video with 5.1 million views on TikTok. “Southwest is wildin’,” reads the caption to the curious clip, which shows the unnamed person nonchalantly lying… […]
    • Beach Boys founder Brian Wilson placed under conservatorship after devastating diagnosis
      (ROLLING STONE) -- Beach Boys founder Brian Wilson was placed in a court-ordered conservatorship Thursday that will be run by his longtime publicist and manager, Jean Sievers, and his longtime business manager, LeeAnn Hard. The reps revealed in a petition filed last February that Wilson is suffering from dementia at the age of 81. Los… […]
    • WATCH: Stand-up comic mercilessly mocks Biden staffer in audience: 'What a [bleep] show'
      WARNING: The video in this story contains some obscenities. (DAILY CALLER) -- Comedian Josh Ocean Thomas savagely mocked an audience member who admitted to working for the Biden administration during his stand-up segment. The video clip is gaining traction online, as internet users flock to hear the brutal jabs. Thomas was on stage at The… […]
    • Polytechnic university goes woke, rolls out DEI initiatives for 20 campus divisions
      (THE COLLEGE FIX) -- A university in Massachusetts dedicated to developing future scientists and engineers also appears to be seriously focused on infusing diversity, equity and inclusion into its programs. Worcester Polytechnic Institute, a 160-year-old institution focused on training students in STEM fields, recently announced that 20 departments, units, schools or other divisions had successfully… […]
    • The insanity at the heart of the Trump trial
      Perhaps the weirdest, and by far the most unjust, thing about former President Donald Trump's trial in New York is that we do not know precisely what crime Trump is charged with committing. We're in the middle of the trial, with Trump facing a maximum of more than 100 years in prison, and we don't… […]
    • A call to confrontation and conflict – to save America
      Let's agree that today's America is not the America of our forefathers. What happened to the American concept of fair play and a can-do spirit we seem so devoid of today? What happened to the rough and tumble, always boisterous America of my youth? Are confrontation and standing up to bullies being strained out of… […]
  • Enter My WorldView