Military Medical Malpractice Laws Under Scrutiny from Lawmakers

By: - February 23, 2019

Amid talks of border security and funding, some lawmakers are taking a crack at systems that prevent military members from pursuing malpractice suits. That’s right—members of the armed forces are prohibited from suing the military (or its practitioners) for medical malpractice.

Jackie Speier (D-CA), the new chairwoman of the House Armed Services personnel subcommittee, brought the issue to the attention of the House and fellow subcommittee members in her first speech.

The Feres Doctrine is the prevailing legal precedent that applies to medical care in the military. Servicemembers “who are injured as a result of military service [are prevented ] from successfully suing the federal government,” according to Cornell Law School’s Legal Information Institute. This means that military members who sustain injuries while performing their military duties are entitled to care but not damages if that care does not successfully remedy their condition. This makes sense on the battlefield or in war, when injuries may outpace the ability of medical treatment available.

However, critics say that the fact that the Feres Doctrine is used to prohibit military members and their families from pursuing medical malpractice claims during routine or non-service related treatment is pushing things too far.

The family of a Navy Lieutenant who died during childbirth was unable to take legal action in 2014. An Army Green Beret battling terminal cancer is suing the Army for misdiagnosing his tumor as pneumonia. If a similar case had occurred with civilian doctors, it would be an obvious case for medical malpractice, said experts who looked at his medical scans.

Speier said that she wanted to “tackle critical issues that impact not only our service members but their families who also bear the burden of sacrifice and commitment to our country,” according to a report published in the Military Times. The responsibility for changing laws rests with Congress. Speier and other lawmakers will be looking at these cases and how the law should be changed in the upcoming weeks.

  • RSS WND

    • Columbia University probing 'Resistance 101' student event where Hamas is hailed
      (NEW YORK JEWISH WEEK) -- Columbia University is investigating a student event where speakers expressed support for Palestinian terror groups and encouraged students to back “armed resistance” against Israel. The event on Sunday, titled “Resistance 101,” was led by Columbia University Apartheid Divest, a coalition of student organizations. The two lead groups in the coalition… […]
    • Former paratrooper makes incredible claim about a crashed UFO being recovered
      (OUTKICK) -- A former paratrooper is making an incredible claim about a crashed UFO being recovered. One of the most stunning claims made by whistleblower David Grusch is that there's some kind of UFO recovery program. Journalist Michael Shellenberger also claimed the government is hiding as many as a dozen downed crafts. Now, a claim… […]
    • Total solar eclipse forecast shows who has best chance for clear skies on April 8
      (FOX WEATHER) -- Early forecasting for the total solar eclipse shows a higher probability of a mostly clear sky along parts of the path of totality in Texas, Oklahoma and Arkansas. On April 8th, a total solar eclipse will be visible across parts of Mexico, Canada and the U.S., from Texas to Maine. A total… […]
    • How young you feel hinges on how well you sleep
      (STUDY FINDS) -- We’ve all heard the adage “you’re only as old as you feel,” but what if your actual age and perceived age don’t quite match up? It turns out that this concept, known as subjective age, can have profound implications for your health and well-being. According to a new study by researchers at… […]
    • Does cinnamon carry the cure for baldness?
      (STUDY FINDS) -- Hair loss, or alopecia, is a common concern that can take a significant emotional toll. While current treatments can help manage symptoms, they often come with side-effects and mixed results. But what if the key to fuller, healthier hair was hiding in your spice rack? Researchers from Yokohama National University in Japan… […]
    • Overlooked sexual health crisis among adults over 50
      (STUDY FINDS) -- If you think sexually transmitted infections (STIs) are just a problem for young people, think again. Cases of gonorrhea, syphilis, chlamydia, and other STIs are rising rapidly in older adults across the world. Yes, grandma and grandpa are getting busy – and forgetting to wrap it up. At the European Congress of… […]
    • Joe Lieberman, Al Gore's 2000 running mate, dead at 82
      (POLITICO) -- Joe Lieberman, a longtime senator from Connecticut who became the first Jewish American to be nominated on a major party’s ticket, died Wednesday. He was 82. Lieberman’s family stated that he died “due to complications from a fall. He was 82 years old. His beloved wife, Hadassah, and members of his family were… […]
    • Thousands baptized after watching 'Duck Dynasty's' Phil Robertson and his story of addiction, redemption
      (CHRISTIAN POST) -- The Robertson family of “Duck Dynasty” fame has always been open about their lives, both good and bad, even candidly depicting Phil Robertson’s early struggles with alcohol addiction in the film “The Blind.” It’s exactly this kind of transparency that has allowed audiences of all backgrounds to feel a genuine connection to… […]
    • WATCH: Country star Reba McEntire shares God secret on 'The Voice'
      (CBN NEWS) -- Country music star and "The Voice" judge, Reba McEntire, recently opened up about how she relies on the Holy Spirit to "put her in the right place" when she performs on stage. The Grammy Award-winning artist got choked up during NBC's "The Voice" Monday night after her team members Josh Sanders and… […]
    • Why no gay golfers on the PGA Tour?
      In 2006, Hawaii-born Tadd Fujikawa played in his one and only major golf championship, the U.S. Open. He did not make the cut. Today, his X page tells us he is the pickleball pro at Sea Island Resort. Despite his humble career, Fujikawa does have one major distinction. When I google "gay golfer," he shows… […]
  • Enter My WorldView