New York Schools Remove Literacy Test for Aspiring Teachers to Increase Diversity

Tags:

Strong command of the English language is not required to teach our students in New York…

The New York state board of regents recently cancelled a required literacy test for aspiring teachers. The Academic Literacy Skills Test (ALST) was intended to ensure strong language skills among aspiring instructors across the state. Test results showed that just 46 percent of Hispanics, 41 percent of African-Americans, and 64 percent of Caucasian candidates passed the exam on the first try. This was understandably embarrassing for aspiring educators. But administrators cancelled the requirement due to cries that the test is redundant for people with college degrees and that it disproportionately affected minority candidates.

Unlike loan officers or business owners, the test is the same no matter who takes it, and it is tough to argue that the inanimate object has malevolent motives against selected groups. I imagine that most leaders interested in the education of their children above fuzzy concepts of social justice would accept those results and emphasize that the state needs better instructors, and should keep their standards as a result.

On top of these watered-down standards borne of racial concerns, I would be incredibly concerned that a significant percentage of teachers have trouble passing what is essentially a high school English test.  Illiterate teachers are a prime example of the problems with licensure programs; the teacher’s license is sold by politicians to the public as a way to increase quality and prevent unqualified instructors in the classroom. (I’m sure the politicians don’t mind the additional test, background check, and other fees associated with the requirement.)  But the licensure requirements do little more than guarantee that somebody is good at navigating the bureaucracy, and it acts as a barrier to those who aren’t.

Nevada, for example, regularly has a shortage of teachers, but they refuse to let those with advanced degrees in their field teach in public schools without the proper credentials. The teaching schools regularly attract candidates in the bottom half of their graduating classes. As we’ve seen in New York, they have trouble passing a basic literacy test. When I inquired about a teacher’s license in Nevada, the “highly qualified instructor” page had several noticeable typos and several homonyms, or words that sound similar but have different meaning and spelling, suggesting that the writer had a very poor command of English.  Needless to say I didn’t walk away with the impression that the school system was run by the very best individuals; the credentialing process ensures high-quality instructors.

From cab companies (which are an especially big special interest here in Las Vegas) to hair stylists to teachers, the government promises that licenses are a way to protect the public. But they end up protecting entrenchment monopolies and their allies in the bureaucracy. In New York, that entrenched interest is the teachers union, which is fully committed to advancing its own interests– they would rather water down standards to attract more minority candidates. Ironically and sadly, this quest to advance minority teachers will likely ensure that minority students are hurt, as they will be taught by substandard, yet fully-licensed instructors.

Morgan Deane is an OpsLens Contributor and a former U.S. Marine Corps infantry rifleman. Deane also served in the National Guard as an Intelligence Analyst.

  • RSS WND

    • Biden's illegals total more than populations of 33 individual states
      By Jake Smith Daily Caller News Foundation Immigration into the U.S. has risen so rapidly that it beat out federal projections by decades, according to a report from the Center for Immigration Studies (CIS) released on Thursday. The total number of immigrants in the U.S. rose to a record high of 51.4 million as of… […]
    • Microsoft cautions developers to avoid curvy female characters
      (NICHE GAMER) – Microsoft urges developers not to create female characters with “exaggerated body proportions” on their official site to support game devs. The site, titled “Product Inclusion Action: Help Customers Feel Seen” includes a bullet list of considerations they urge developers to make when working on their product. One Twitter user pointed out the… […]
    • London's Globe Theater slaps Shakespeare plays with 'trigger warnings'
      (THE NATIONAL PULSE) – Productions of famed Shakespeare plays such as Antony and Cleopatra, Romeo and Juliet, and Julius Caesar at Shakespeare’s Globe Theatre, London, have recently been given “content guidance” trigger warnings. These advance notices caution viewers about depictions of suicide, violence, war, and “misogynoir references” — a newspeak term fusing misogyny and ‘racism’… […]
    • World's fastest camera shoots at 156.3 trillion frames per second
      (NEW ATLAS) – Engineers at INRS Énergie Matériaux Télécommunications Research Centre in Canada have developed the world’s fastest camera, which can shoot at an astonishing 156.3 trillion frames per second (fps). The best slow-mo cameras in phones are usually working with a few hundred fps. Professional cinematic cameras might use a few thousand, to achieve… […]
    • Arnold Schwarzenegger undergoes major heart surgery
      (NEWS ADDICTS) – Fully vaccinated Hollywood star Arnold Schwarzenegger has just revealed that he’s had a pacemaker installed after undergoing three major open heart surgeries. The 76-year-old said he now has a ‘machine part’, just like his Terminator character – and has said he will have to take a break from the gym. Get the… […]
    • Columbia University probing 'Resistance 101' student event where Hamas is hailed
      (NEW YORK JEWISH WEEK) -- Columbia University is investigating a student event where speakers expressed support for Palestinian terror groups and encouraged students to back “armed resistance” against Israel. The event on Sunday, titled “Resistance 101,” was led by Columbia University Apartheid Divest, a coalition of student organizations. The two lead groups in the coalition… […]
    • Former paratrooper makes incredible claim about a crashed UFO being recovered
      (OUTKICK) -- A former paratrooper is making an incredible claim about a crashed UFO being recovered. One of the most stunning claims made by whistleblower David Grusch is that there's some kind of UFO recovery program. Journalist Michael Shellenberger also claimed the government is hiding as many as a dozen downed crafts. Now, a claim… […]
    • Total solar eclipse forecast shows who has best chance for clear skies on April 8
      (FOX WEATHER) -- Early forecasting for the total solar eclipse shows a higher probability of a mostly clear sky along parts of the path of totality in Texas, Oklahoma and Arkansas. On April 8th, a total solar eclipse will be visible across parts of Mexico, Canada and the U.S., from Texas to Maine. A total… […]
    • How young you feel hinges on how well you sleep
      (STUDY FINDS) -- We’ve all heard the adage “you’re only as old as you feel,” but what if your actual age and perceived age don’t quite match up? It turns out that this concept, known as subjective age, can have profound implications for your health and well-being. According to a new study by researchers at… […]
    • Does cinnamon carry the cure for baldness?
      (STUDY FINDS) -- Hair loss, or alopecia, is a common concern that can take a significant emotional toll. While current treatments can help manage symptoms, they often come with side-effects and mixed results. But what if the key to fuller, healthier hair was hiding in your spice rack? Researchers from Yokohama National University in Japan… […]
  • Enter My WorldView