The Attempt to Hoodwink the U.S. Into a Cold War With Russia

By: - August 2, 2021

Source link


For years conservative movement figures have engaged in “value talk,” a rhetorical means of winning acceptance for pet causes that often have little to do with conservatism or traditional morality. Such value talk has often been used as a way of prodding Washington into foreign entanglements. 


Leon Aron’s recent article for The Dispatch, “Welcome to the new Cold War” is a case in point. An “incompatibility of values” between the Biden administration and Russian President Vladimir Putin’s regime has transformed Russia into a greater security threat to the United States than was the former Soviet Union, Aron writes. Aron, a Senior Fellow at the center-right think tank American Enterprise Institute, does not mince words. “The ideology of the Putin regime,” the subheadline of his piece reads, “is hardly less toxic and is perhaps more incendiary than communist totalitarianism.”


This version of anti-Russian saber-rattling might have made a bit of sense during tense moments in the real Cold War, such as in the harsh exchanges between Washington and Moscow over the Soviet downing of Korean Air Lines Flight 007 in 1983. But in 2021, Aron’s analysis of U.S.-Russian relations has all the signs of an establishment conservative’s clumsy attempt to build bridges with the Biden administration and the globalist left.


These signs are seen throughout Aron’s article. While Cold War conservatives talked about a missile gap between the Soviet Union and the United States, Aron, by contrast, refers to “the normative gap between the liberal democracies and the system that Putin assiduously forged.”


Aron also maintains that Putin is not to be trusted. His sinister talent lies in his “ability to bend to his will millions of his compatriots.” Foremost among Putin’s crimes, according to Aron, is his success at convincing millions of Russians that “Russia’s national identity” is based on her military victories, notably in World War II. Putin’s “militarized patriotism in peacetime,” in other words, stands in stark contrast to America’s “democratic” values.


While Aron is quite specific about Putin’s supposed values, his vagueness about America’s democratic values is curious, to say the least. Do American values include gay marriage? Transgenderism? Black Lives Matter? Who knows? The ambiguity surrounding Aron’s definition of American “values” suggests a familiar ploy on the part of movement conservatives: hiding bellicose foreign policy objectives behind rhetoric about American obligations to defend what Aron calls the “Democratic West.” 


Recent events give us a clue as to Aron’s intentions. He surely knows that at least since 2016, America’s elites in the mainstream media, intelligence agencies, entertainment industries, and universities have been chattering about Putin’s alleged meddling in U.S. national politics, his clampdown on dissent, and his aggressive foreign policy in places like Ukraine and Syria. In 2019, Hillary Clinton seriously claimed that Putin was “grooming” fellow Democrat Tulsi Gabbard for a third-party run for the presidency. Joe Biden called Putin “a killer” last March, which is only marginally worse than Aron’s description of Putin as “a diminutive hooligan from the slums of post-war Leningrad.”


It’s not just the Biden Democrats who find themselves in a stand-off with Putin. Russia’s Foreign Ministry announced in April 2021 that it would “bring to an end” the activities of U.S.-funded foundations and nongovernmental organizations (NGOs) within Russia. One month later, Russia declared New York’s Bard College an “undesirable” organization “threatening Russia’s constitutional order and security.” Russia’s step means Bard must cease all activities in Russia, notably its relationship with St. Petersburg State University.


Bard College President Leon Botstein said he was “heartbroken” about what he called a “blacklisting.” But recent events suggest that Botstein, who sits with George Soros on the Open Society Foundations Global Board of advisors, could hardly be surprised by Russia’s decision. Soros, the billionaire international financier and founder of Open Society Foundations—banned in Russia in 2015 as an “undesirable” NGO—has been a generous Bard donor for some time. Indeed, shortly before Russia’s banning of Bard, the college announced it had received a Soros endowment pledge of $500 million.


From the standpoint of 2021, then, Aron’s thesis that America and Russia are in a new cold war pitting democracy against the militarist Putin is sure to find receptive ears not just in the Biden White House, but also among the globalist, Soros-funded forces that view the Russian president as a dire threat to the Western left’s definition of democratic governance and human rights.


Last but not least, Aron’s charge that Putinism is “perhaps more incendiary than communist totalitarianism” is strange coming from someone touted to be an expert on all things Russian. Few would deny that Putin’s regime resembles a “corrupt autocracy founded on propaganda, political manipulation, and repression.” Or that Putin pursues geopolitical objectives in eastern Europe, Central Asia, the Middle East, and the Far East. So what else is new in Russian history? These were prominent features of the Czarist era Russian rulers as well.


No scholar would deny that corruption, political manipulation, and repression were hallmark features of Soviet communism. Thus it is hard to take Aron seriously when he asserts that Putin’s propaganda is more toxic than the Soviet version, which used to highlight the inevitability of communism’s triumph. Aron seems to have forgotten that countless fellow-travelers and secret communists once propagandized Soviet doctrines on American soil during the Cold War.


Aron’s rhetoric about a “new Cold War” with Russia may seduce some in the conservative movement, but they shouldn’t fall for it. Aron likely has a different audience  in mind, one that includes Joe Biden’s National Security Council, the likes of Elizabeth Warren and Nancy Pelosi, and the host of NGOs which seek to operate on Russian soil in the name of “human rights.”  And Aron’s target audience certainly doesn’t include Trump voters.



Dear Readers,


Big Tech is suppressing our reach, refusing to let us advertise and squelching our ability to serve up a steady diet of truth and ideas. Help us fight back by becoming a member for just $5 a month and then join the discussion on Parler @CharlemagneInstitute and Gab @CharlemagneInstitute!


Ian Dowbiggin teaches the history of the environmentalist movement at the University of Prince Edward Island. He is a Fellow of the Royal Society of Canada and the author of The Sterilization Movement and Global Fertility in the Twentieth Century.


  • RSS WND

    • Columbia University probing 'Resistance 101' student event where Hamas is hailed
      (NEW YORK JEWISH WEEK) -- Columbia University is investigating a student event where speakers expressed support for Palestinian terror groups and encouraged students to back “armed resistance” against Israel. The event on Sunday, titled “Resistance 101,” was led by Columbia University Apartheid Divest, a coalition of student organizations. The two lead groups in the coalition… […]
    • Former paratrooper makes incredible claim about a crashed UFO being recovered
      (OUTKICK) -- A former paratrooper is making an incredible claim about a crashed UFO being recovered. One of the most stunning claims made by whistleblower David Grusch is that there's some kind of UFO recovery program. Journalist Michael Shellenberger also claimed the government is hiding as many as a dozen downed crafts. Now, a claim… […]
    • Total solar eclipse forecast shows who has best chance for clear skies on April 8
      (FOX WEATHER) -- Early forecasting for the total solar eclipse shows a higher probability of a mostly clear sky along parts of the path of totality in Texas, Oklahoma and Arkansas. On April 8th, a total solar eclipse will be visible across parts of Mexico, Canada and the U.S., from Texas to Maine. A total… […]
    • How young you feel hinges on how well you sleep
      (STUDY FINDS) -- We’ve all heard the adage “you’re only as old as you feel,” but what if your actual age and perceived age don’t quite match up? It turns out that this concept, known as subjective age, can have profound implications for your health and well-being. According to a new study by researchers at… […]
    • Does cinnamon carry the cure for baldness?
      (STUDY FINDS) -- Hair loss, or alopecia, is a common concern that can take a significant emotional toll. While current treatments can help manage symptoms, they often come with side-effects and mixed results. But what if the key to fuller, healthier hair was hiding in your spice rack? Researchers from Yokohama National University in Japan… […]
    • Overlooked sexual health crisis among adults over 50
      (STUDY FINDS) -- If you think sexually transmitted infections (STIs) are just a problem for young people, think again. Cases of gonorrhea, syphilis, chlamydia, and other STIs are rising rapidly in older adults across the world. Yes, grandma and grandpa are getting busy – and forgetting to wrap it up. At the European Congress of… […]
    • Joe Lieberman, Al Gore's 2000 running mate, dead at 82
      (POLITICO) -- Joe Lieberman, a longtime senator from Connecticut who became the first Jewish American to be nominated on a major party’s ticket, died Wednesday. He was 82. Lieberman’s family stated that he died “due to complications from a fall. He was 82 years old. His beloved wife, Hadassah, and members of his family were… […]
    • Thousands baptized after watching 'Duck Dynasty's' Phil Robertson and his story of addiction, redemption
      (CHRISTIAN POST) -- The Robertson family of “Duck Dynasty” fame has always been open about their lives, both good and bad, even candidly depicting Phil Robertson’s early struggles with alcohol addiction in the film “The Blind.” It’s exactly this kind of transparency that has allowed audiences of all backgrounds to feel a genuine connection to… […]
    • WATCH: Country star Reba McEntire shares God secret on 'The Voice'
      (CBN NEWS) -- Country music star and "The Voice" judge, Reba McEntire, recently opened up about how she relies on the Holy Spirit to "put her in the right place" when she performs on stage. The Grammy Award-winning artist got choked up during NBC's "The Voice" Monday night after her team members Josh Sanders and… […]
    • Why no gay golfers on the PGA Tour?
      In 2006, Hawaii-born Tadd Fujikawa played in his one and only major golf championship, the U.S. Open. He did not make the cut. Today, his X page tells us he is the pickleball pro at Sea Island Resort. Despite his humble career, Fujikawa does have one major distinction. When I google "gay golfer," he shows… […]
  • Enter My WorldView