United Overbooks Flight, Forcibly Drags Passenger Off Plane to Make Room for Crew, Bloodies Lip

Rather than find a sensible solution to a problem the company created, United chose violence…

Video appeared online late Sunday night showing a United Airlines passenger getting dragged off of a plane. The airline had overbooked and needed four seats for their employees to make their connecting flights. They first offered 400 dollars and a replacement flight, then 800 dollars and a replacement flight. Nobody volunteered so, apparently being inspired by the Hunger Games, they randomly selected four passengers. One of the men selected claimed to be a doctor who had patients he needed to see Monday morning and couldn’t give up his flight. Showing the kind of sensitive customer service that is the subject of this post, United Airlines summoned three security personnel to drag him from the plane. In doing so they busted his lip and as you can see in the disturbing video, he was rather disheveled as well.

We don’t know the entire situation, but we do know that a stupefying and inflexible solution to a problem is typical of every bureaucracy. No matter how noble the intention of the bureaucrat or bill, it still produces unintended consequences that usually hurt people.  So a bill designed to make health insurance more available, results in millions losing their insurance, bills designed to create affordable housing lead to the most expensive housing markets in the country, tax increases designed to raise revenue are dodged and end up producing less revenue, and a school nutritionist hired to help kids be healthy and happy, thinks it’s appropriate to take away school lunches from hungry children.  This is why people must separate the idealistic rhetoric used by politicians to justify a new law or course of action, with its possible and unintended side effects.

But in this case, the forcible removal seemed like an intended policy! United could have chosen any number of alternatives to avoid arriving at the point where they forcibly remove a passenger that paid for his ticket. In the pursuit of profits that come from full flights – not mostly full flights – their first mistake was allowing customers to overbook the flight. They could have figured out another way to move their personnel or simply had their staff wait for another flight, thus suffering the consequences of the company’s decisions. Sure, that isn’t ideal, but it shouldn’t be that difficult to put customers first especially after the company created the problem in the first place. They could have offered even more significant compensation that would have induced volunteers to give up their seats.  I’m pretty chill and wouldn’t have minded trading an extra night in town for a good meal, nice hotel room, and a first class seat the next morning. But I was not there and people have unique priorities.

Sadly, the airline didn’t do any of those things. They relied upon brute force to solve a problem caused by their capricious judgement and inflexible policies. Stories like this happen all the time. Faceless government or corporate bureaucrats rarely craft well thought out policies that can create sensitive and timely solutions.  Instead, customers that paid for a flight are given a bloody lip and dragged from the aircraft.

Morgan Deane is an OpsLens Contributor and a former U.S. Marine Corps infantry rifleman. Deane also served in the National Guard as an Intelligence Analyst. He is the author of the forthcoming book Decisive Battles in Chinese history, as well as Bleached Bones and Wicked Serpents: Ancient Warfare in the Book of Mormon.

  • RSS WND

    • Columbia University probing 'Resistance 101' student event where Hamas is hailed
      (NEW YORK JEWISH WEEK) -- Columbia University is investigating a student event where speakers expressed support for Palestinian terror groups and encouraged students to back “armed resistance” against Israel. The event on Sunday, titled “Resistance 101,” was led by Columbia University Apartheid Divest, a coalition of student organizations. The two lead groups in the coalition… […]
    • Former paratrooper makes incredible claim about a crashed UFO being recovered
      (OUTKICK) -- A former paratrooper is making an incredible claim about a crashed UFO being recovered. One of the most stunning claims made by whistleblower David Grusch is that there's some kind of UFO recovery program. Journalist Michael Shellenberger also claimed the government is hiding as many as a dozen downed crafts. Now, a claim… […]
    • Total solar eclipse forecast shows who has best chance for clear skies on April 8
      (FOX WEATHER) -- Early forecasting for the total solar eclipse shows a higher probability of a mostly clear sky along parts of the path of totality in Texas, Oklahoma and Arkansas. On April 8th, a total solar eclipse will be visible across parts of Mexico, Canada and the U.S., from Texas to Maine. A total… […]
    • How young you feel hinges on how well you sleep
      (STUDY FINDS) -- We’ve all heard the adage “you’re only as old as you feel,” but what if your actual age and perceived age don’t quite match up? It turns out that this concept, known as subjective age, can have profound implications for your health and well-being. According to a new study by researchers at… […]
    • Does cinnamon carry the cure for baldness?
      (STUDY FINDS) -- Hair loss, or alopecia, is a common concern that can take a significant emotional toll. While current treatments can help manage symptoms, they often come with side-effects and mixed results. But what if the key to fuller, healthier hair was hiding in your spice rack? Researchers from Yokohama National University in Japan… […]
    • Overlooked sexual health crisis among adults over 50
      (STUDY FINDS) -- If you think sexually transmitted infections (STIs) are just a problem for young people, think again. Cases of gonorrhea, syphilis, chlamydia, and other STIs are rising rapidly in older adults across the world. Yes, grandma and grandpa are getting busy – and forgetting to wrap it up. At the European Congress of… […]
    • Joe Lieberman, Al Gore's 2000 running mate, dead at 82
      (POLITICO) -- Joe Lieberman, a longtime senator from Connecticut who became the first Jewish American to be nominated on a major party’s ticket, died Wednesday. He was 82. Lieberman’s family stated that he died “due to complications from a fall. He was 82 years old. His beloved wife, Hadassah, and members of his family were… […]
    • Thousands baptized after watching 'Duck Dynasty's' Phil Robertson and his story of addiction, redemption
      (CHRISTIAN POST) -- The Robertson family of “Duck Dynasty” fame has always been open about their lives, both good and bad, even candidly depicting Phil Robertson’s early struggles with alcohol addiction in the film “The Blind.” It’s exactly this kind of transparency that has allowed audiences of all backgrounds to feel a genuine connection to… […]
    • WATCH: Country star Reba McEntire shares God secret on 'The Voice'
      (CBN NEWS) -- Country music star and "The Voice" judge, Reba McEntire, recently opened up about how she relies on the Holy Spirit to "put her in the right place" when she performs on stage. The Grammy Award-winning artist got choked up during NBC's "The Voice" Monday night after her team members Josh Sanders and… […]
    • Why no gay golfers on the PGA Tour?
      In 2006, Hawaii-born Tadd Fujikawa played in his one and only major golf championship, the U.S. Open. He did not make the cut. Today, his X page tells us he is the pickleball pro at Sea Island Resort. Despite his humble career, Fujikawa does have one major distinction. When I google "gay golfer," he shows… […]
  • Enter My WorldView